TR

Season 2, Episode 4

You Can't Always Get What You Want

5.9/ 10October 12, 200443 min

Brooke's new neighbor quickly makes his presence felt among the Tree Hill gang and even comes to Brooke's rescue when she is caught shoplifting. Nathan and Haley have their first post-wedding argument when he buys her a gift rather than a much-needed car. Lucas' attempt to help Dan with rehab ends in disaster when Dan reverts to his old ways. Peyton tries to organize an all-ages club and is tempted to try cocaine to seal the deal.

Directed by
Joanna Kerns
Written by
Jennifer Cecil

Guest stars

All episodes — Season 2

Open season page
  1. S2 E1

    The Desperate Kingdom of Love

    Sep 21, 20048.343 min

    After Lucas and Keith learn that Dan had a heart attack and is still in the hospital, they decide it is best for them to return to Tree Hill. When Deb learns about Haley and Nathan's marriage, she grows hostile. Meanwhile, angry that Lucas

  2. S2 E2

    The Truth Doesn't Make a Noise

    Sep 28, 20048.443 min

    With the assistance of Peyton and Brooke, Lucas throws Nathan and Haley a wedding reception. Although Haley's parents support the marriage, Deb has a difficult time accepting it. Meanwhile, Dan's recent heart attack causes him to try and me

  3. S2 E3

    Near Wild Heaven

    Oct 5, 200441 min

    Although Nathan and Haley are already married, Tim insists on throwing Nathan a post-wedding bachelor party, while Brooke throws Haley a bachelorette party. Meanwhile, Lucas tries to decide whether he should visit Dan in the hospital. Karen

  4. S2 E5

    I Will Dare

    Oct 19, 2004643 min

    Felix organizes a "dare night" to test the limits of his new classmates. While out playing the game, Lucas meets a mysterious new girl, Anna, and the two of them seem to hit it off. Peyton tearfully confesses to the church that she recently

  5. S2 E6

    We Might as Well Be Strangers

    Oct 26, 20047.843 min

    After Dare Night resulted in new arrangements, a midnight meteor shower finds Lucas sharing a romantic night with Anna. Andy surprises Karen with a dinner and Keith cooks for Jules on their first date. Brooke finds herself forming a mutuall

  6. S2 E7

    Let the Reigns Go Loose

    Nov 2, 200443 min

    The opening of Karen's club "Tric" brings together the people of Tree Hill. Lucas and Felix come to blows over Anna. After Chris quits his gig the night of the club opening, Haley must face her fear of performing to save the night for Peyto