“The real story is just beneath the surface.”
A ragtag crew of podcasters sets out to investigate mysterious disappearances from decades earlier in a charming Irish town with dark, dreadful secrets.
- Created by
- Jez Scharf

“The real story is just beneath the surface.”
A ragtag crew of podcasters sets out to investigate mysterious disappearances from decades earlier in a charming Irish town with dark, dreadful secrets.
1 season · 7 episodes

S1 E1One True Mystery
May 9, 20246.848 min
A hard-nosed journalist grudgingly works with a true-crime podcaster on a strange case in a small Irish town where the locals want to bury the past.
S1 E2Who We Are
May 9, 2024745 min
Dove and Gilbert clash over their differing interview approaches — but as they inch closer to answers, their personal struggles add to their problems.
S1 E3Perfectly Innocent Life
May 9, 20246.953 min
The group digs for more clues after a beloved local's death. New details about the Samhain disappearances force Dove to wade through murky territory.
S1 E4Poison or Something
May 9, 20246.457 min
The crew's investigation takes a bizarre turn, jeopardizing their podcast. Gilbert attempts to settle a debt, while Dove gives Emmy harsh advice.
S1 E5Peace in Our Time
May 9, 20245.948 min
Gilbert learns about Bodkin's shady dealings. Dove stirs up trouble at the pub. With new evidence, the crew pieces together a shocking narrative.
S1 E6Ends Justify Means
May 9, 20246.245 min
Back at Inish Mac Tire, Dove and Emmy seek answers but get sidetracked by troubling visions — and revelations. Gilbert deals with a daunting dilemma.