Following a drunken altercation outside a Long Island Nightclub, a mystery gunman fires several shots injuring a club doorman; the whole incident is captured on CCTV and the next day the accused is arrested and charged with Assault in the First-Degree; the Defense argues the footage is inconclusive; is the accused a victim of mistaken identity, or is he guilty as charged?
All episodes — Season 8
Open season page
S8 E1Teenage Killer or Framed Victim? - Part 1
Jul 30, 202643 min
When a young man is found stabbed to death, police follow a trail of blood to a trailer; a shocking tale emerges of a robbery honeytrap gone wrong; as a teenage boy faces a Capital Murder charge, his Defense team claims he is being set up b
S8 E2Teenage Killer or Framed Victim? - Part 2
Jul 30, 202643 min
When a young man is found stabbed to death, police follow a trail of blood to a trailer; a shocking tale emerges of a robbery honeytrap gone wrong; as a teenage boy faces a Capital Murder charge, his Defense team claims he is being set up b
S8 E3Negligent Father or Tragic Accident?
Aug 6, 202643 min
In Pennsylvania's Mennonite community a father takes his young daughter out on the farm for the tobacco harvest; tragically she falls to her death under the wheel of a horse drawn wagon; is the father following centuries of family tradition
S8 E4Road Rage Murder or Self-Defense Shooting?
Aug 6, 202643 min
On a regular Saturday morning drive, a father of two becomes involved in an altercation at an intersection; believing his life is threatened, he shoots and kills the other motorist; the Prosecution say the deceased posed no physical threat;
S8 E6Love Rival Killer or Defensive Mom?
Aug 13, 202643 min
A pregnant mother gets into an altercation with her boyfriend's ex; when the mother is maced, she grabs her gun and shoots, fatally wounding the ex-girlfriend; a reckless killing or a woman defending herself and her unborn twins?
- 7S8 E7
High Speed Driver or Tragic Accident?
Aug 20, 202643 min
An intimate account of what happens when someone is formally charged with a crime and sent to trial as told by the perspective of the accused, their legal team and their family members.